What’s Really Happening When Your Team Gets Stuck
You know that feeling when a meeting goes in circles? When the same concerns surface repeatedly, but nothing moves forward? When tension simmers just below the surface, but everyone stays polite?
Most facilitators and leaders recognize these moments. What’s harder is knowing what to do about them.
With Waterline Co-op, I recently completed training in the Lewis Deep Democracy method, a conflict engagement approach that’s transforming how I support groups through their stickiest challenges. I’m now exploring how to bring these new tools to my facilitation practice.
The Iceberg: what you’re not seeing
Imagine your group meet on an iceberg. Everything visible: the stated agenda, discussed topics, official positions is above the waterline. But the depth of the team meeting lies below: hidden group dynamics, unspoken emotions, power struggles… the real reasons you’re stuck.
When groups can’t make decisions or keep cycling through the same conversations, the answer isn’t in what’s being said. It’s in what hasn’t been said yet.
The goal isn’t to force people to speak up. It’s to create enough space so that they can.
The Resistance Line: what’s below the surface
Resistance is a powerful diagnostic tool. When people disagree with the prevailing direction but can’t say so openly, these behaviours may show up:
- Jokes (funny not funny)
- Sarcasm with an edge
- Repeated excuses (“I’ll get to that next week”)
- Gossip and side conversations
- Communication breakdowns
- Outright disruption
Each stage signals that wisdom isn’t being heard. The longer conversations stay below the waterline, the more contentious the conflict becomes. Inviting the group to notice these behaviours can shift the energy in the room. Resistance is an invitation to lower the waterline and bring hidden concerns into the open before they escalate.
The Debate Tool: get it out in the open
When polarization emerges, the Debate Tool engages it directly, not to win, but to stay in relationship. To hold space for debate:
- Guidelines are established as a group
- Each side of the debate is voiced, one perspective at a time without interruption
- Avoid any back-and-forth “tennis match”
- Once perspectives are out in the open, participants share what resonated or shifted their understanding
- Decisions emerge from insights, not power struggles
The Quantum View: see groups as energy fields
I found this part of the training so interesting. Drawing from quantum physics, groups aren’t just collections of individuals… they’re energy fields where roles are fluid.
That “difficult person” who always plays devil’s advocate? They’re carrying something for the entire group. When we project uncomfortable roles onto one person, we avoid owning our part of the dynamic. Acknowledging and owning projections can lead to personal growth and group transformation. It can also unburden the individual who feels forced to play that role.
Role fluidity means recognizing that group issues belong to everyone, not just the person voicing them. When someone consistently plays a role (archetypes like the skeptic, the cheerleader, the peacemaker), it’s often because the group needs that energy.
What This Means for Your Organization
Whether I’m designing planning sessions or facilitating board retreats, these principles inform everything:
Check-ins and check-outs matter – Not as feel-good rituals, but as diagnostic tools to identify group dynamics and create space for genuine presence, connection and reflection
Silence signals wisdom – When groups go quiet, something important is trying to emerge
Conflict is information – Tension points to where innovation and creativity are waiting to be unlocked
Addressing dynamics in a small team can ripple through an entire organization. Sometimes working with one team creates the shift everyone needs.
True facilitation creates conditions for groups to access their own wisdom. This training deepened my understanding of how to do that—especially when stakes are high, emotions run strong, and people need to stay in relationship while working through their differences.
If your organization is navigating change, making tough decisions, or stuck in patterns that aren’t serving you, let’s talk about how these approaches might support your work.
The answer to what’s keeping you stuck is already in the room. Sometimes you just need help bringing it to the surface.
Get facilitation support to guide your next meeting
Interested in facilitation that goes beyond surface-level consensus?
Get in touch to explore how these engagement tools could support your team.